[Card Creation] Blue regenerating creature?

"Klaus Mittag" <mittag RemoveThis @informatik.uni-frankfurt.de> wrote in message
news:3glbs6FcnprdU1@news.dfncis.de...
> Erich Leibrock <eleibrock RemoveThis @symdeletethecapspatico.ca> wrote:
>> OK, I've decided to come up with a blue regenerating creature that
>> doesn't
>> require a second colour anywhere (ability copying doesn't count, sorry
>> Quicksilver Elemental). Thus far, I've found three entire cards:
>
>> Ghost Ship
>> Sea Troll
>> Spiny Starfish
>
>> The Sea Troll's ability is only good against blue, so that's out the
>> window.
>> What that leaves is Ghost Ship and Spiny Starfish. I don't need to be
>> able
>> to make tokens, I just want something playable. So, how about:
>
>> CARDNAME
>> 2U
>> Creature - CREATURETYPES
>> 1/2
>> Flying
>> Whenever a player plays an instant, you may regenerate target creature.
>
> Regeneration just isn't considered a particularly blue ability these days
> (and
> if I look at the above three cards, probably never was -- Sea Troll, as
> you
> mention, is pretty limited, the Starfish has wimpy base stats, and the
> Ghost
> Ship, arguably the best of the bunch, requires a whopping three blue mana
> in
> order to regenerate). Blue can *already* save creatures by bouncing them
> back
> to their owner's hand, counterspelling the threat, making them
> untargetable,
> phasing them out, whatever...and you miss *regeneration*? (Which half
> the
> time doesn't help anyway because of all the 'that creature can't
> regenerate'
> effects flying about.)

I know Blue isn't known for regenerating. However, I don't see a problem
with there being a blue regenerator coming up every, oh, say three or four
blocks or so, that doesn't have to rely on another colour or a card like
Dream Thrush to convert your own land into the colour you need. Also, a
buddy of mine (and I can just see Dave DeLaney shaking his head as he reads
this) are designing our own block, with part of the key being allowing
colours to do things (even if badly) that they don't get a chance to do
otherwise. Example: We have a red spell that reads, in part, 'Destroy target
enchantment.' Of course, said card costs more to play then, say, a standard
LD spell, but it also deals damage to the enchantment's controller.

> That said, I suppose it might be in flavor for blue to have a regenerator
> with
> some weird drawback. Say...
>
> Soldevi Cloud Sentry
> 2U
> Creature -- Human Minion (or whatever)
> 1/2
> Flying
> U: Regenerate Soldevi Cloud Sentry. Target opponent may draw a card.
>
> CoP: Red laid in.

Cute Altho my *ONLY* problem with that is it feeds Red more burn, so it
kinda saves Red that way too. What about a Flicker-type effect - which feels
like Phasing to me

Randomflappyregeneratingweenie
2U
Creautre - Randomflappyregeneratingweeniecreaturetype
1/2
Flying
Whenever an opponent plays an instant, you may pay U. If you do, remove
target creature from the game, then return it to play at the end of turn.

Erich

Erich Leibrock <eleibrock.RemoveThis@symdeletethecapspatico.ca> wrote:

> Cute Altho my *ONLY* problem with that is it feeds Red more burn, so it
> kinda saves Red that way too. What about a Flicker-type effect - which feels
> like Phasing to me

> Randomflappyregeneratingweenie
> 2U
> Creautre - Randomflappyregeneratingweeniecreaturetype
> 1/2
> Flying
> Whenever an opponent plays an instant, you may pay U. If you do, remove
> target creature from the game, then return it to play at the end of turn.

> Erich

Well, this one doesn't seem to be regenerating anymore, does it? Looks
reasonable at first glance, though. Some playtesting to see if that ability
is costed just right might be in order.

--
Klaus Mittag (mittag@informatik.uni-frankfurt.de)
#include <disclaimer.h>
#include <fancysig.h>
spam > /dev/null

"Klaus Mittag" <mittag RemoveThis @informatik.uni-frankfurt.de> wrote in message
news:3glv0sFd4tabU1@news.dfncis.de...
> Erich Leibrock <eleibrock RemoveThis @symdeletethecapspatico.ca> wrote:
>
>> Cute Altho my *ONLY* problem with that is it feeds Red more burn, so
>> it
>> kinda saves Red that way too. What about a Flicker-type effect - which
>> feels
>> like Phasing to me
>
>> Randomflappyregeneratingweenie
>> 2U
>> Creautre - Randomflappyregeneratingweeniecreaturetype
>> 1/2
>> Flying
>> Whenever an opponent plays an instant, you may pay U. If you do, remove
>> target creature from the game, then return it to play at the end of turn.
>
>> Erich
>
> Well, this one doesn't seem to be regenerating anymore, does it? Looks
> reasonable at first glance, though. Some playtesting to see if that
> ability
> is costed just right might be in order.

The fun part is figuring out how to make it feel, well, blue. I will say
this: Ghost Ship in Shandalar was a pain in the ass to deal with

Erich